On Wednesday , the European Union ’s highest court formally rule that Apple is n’t the only company that can “ think unlike ” anymore . The bloc ’s Court of Justice on Wednesdayofficially rejectedthe technical school titan ’ bid to take onto its EU trademark of its once - iconic catchword , giving any non - Apple caller in the neighborhood the right wing to poach the tagline .
The decision is the result of a request from Swatch . The Swiss watchmaker utilize with EU authorities to have Apple ’s trademark annulled in 2016 on the basis that Apple just was n’t using the slogan anymore — and Swatch , on the other helping hand , was actively using the phrase “ Tick Different ” in itsown merchandising campaigns .
The European Courts take Swatch ’s side . In the foregone yr of 2018 , regulators note at the meter , Apple ’s only examples of telling customers to “ opine different ” were occasional blips on the Apple website “ to commemorate far-famed people or special consequence . ” The company had n’t made use of the slogan in a fashion that require trademarking for about a X , the court found .
Photo: Justin Sullivan (Getty Images)
Apple appeal the determination The courtsheld firm . In mid-2019 , Applefiled a casein Swiss tribunal to finish Swatch ’s use of the catchword . It was dismissed . At the jump of 2021 , Apple bring thee actions against Swatch before the General Court of the EU . And today , those got fire , too :
The Court remark that , wayward to what Apple claims , the Board of Appeal ’s conclusion as to the specialty of the contested marks is not oppose by a body of evidence aimed at prove that they have been put to genuine function .
Apple did not immediately answer to a request for input .
Image: Rob Janoff/Wikimedia Commons
The iMac Creator first come up with “ suppose unlike ” as part of an ad campaignin 1997and immediatelyregisteredthat phrase as as a trademark with authorities in both the U.S. , its home base , and in the EU . The Court ’s declaration remark that Apple register that same trademark again in 1998 and 2005 , ostensibly because the caller has always lovedhoarding hallmark .
Suffice to say , it ’s not 2005 anymore . The iPhone did n’t even live then . The company has n’t narrate its customers to “ cerebrate unlike ” about their iPhones or Macbook Pros in class . The phrasal idiom appear nowhere in itsannual developer ’ league , WWDC , just a few day ago .
AppleComputingiPhoneiPhone 7Steve Jobs
Daily Newsletter
Get the best tech , science , and culture newsworthiness in your inbox day by day .
News from the time to come , delivered to your present .
You May Also Like
